Verdict Archive

What the courts decided

Case file · Superior Court, Bristol County (sitting at New Bedford), Massachusetts, United States

Lizzie Andrew Borden: charges, verdict and sentence

Commonwealth
v.
Lizzie A. Borden
Superior Court, Bristol County (sitting at New Bedford), Massachusetts, United States · 1892 to 1893

Lizzie Borden was arrested in Fall River, Massachusetts, in August 1892 and indicted by a Bristol County grand jury on murder charges arising from the deaths of her father and stepmother. A jury in New Bedford acquitted her on 20 June 1893.

Where it stands nowBorden was acquitted on 20 June 1893 and died on 1 June 1927.

Charges and outcomes

ChargeOutcomeDate
Murder (deaths of her father and stepmother, August 1892)1,2Acquitted20 June 1893

Sentence

None. She was acquitted.

Court record, stage by stage

  1. indictmentClosed inquest held from 9 to 11 August 18921
    Fall River inquest
  2. arrestArrested by the Fall River city marshal1,2
  3. indictmentEntered a plea of not guilty and was held at the jail in Taunton1
    Fall River District Court
  4. indictmentAt a preliminary hearing on 22 and 23 August, Judge Josiah Blaisdell found probable cause to hold her for trial1
    Fall River District Court
  5. indictmentIndicted for murder by a Bristol County grand jury empanelled on 7 November 18922
    Bristol County grand jury
  6. trialJury trial opened at the New Bedford courthouse1,2
    Superior Court, New Bedford
  7. verdictAll male jury returned a verdict of not guilty1,2
    Superior Court, New Bedford
  8. deathDied at age 671

Sources

  1. Famous Trials, Professor Douglas O. Linder, UMKC School of Law, The Trial of Lizzie Borden: A Chronology
  2. ABA Journal, Dec. 2, 1892: Grand jury indicts Lizzie Borden

This file describes court proceedings. It does not describe or name victims beyond the court record. Our standards.