Verdict Archive

What the courts decided

All case files

24 criminal cases, each traced from charge to final outcome using court records.

DefendantCourtYearsOutcome
Aileen Carol WuornosFlorida circuit courts (Volusia, Dixie and other counties), United States1991 to 2002Convicted
Amanda Marie KnoxCorte d'assise di Perugia, Florence Court of Appeal and Supreme Court of Cassation, Italy2007 to 2025Convicted
Bernard Lawrence MadoffU.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, United States2009 to 2021Pleaded guilty
Casey Marie AnthonyNinth Judicial Circuit Court, Orange County, Florida, United States2008 to 2013Conviction overturned
Charles Milles MansonLos Angeles County Superior Court, California, United States1969 to 2017Convicted
Christa Gail PikeKnox County Criminal Court, Tennessee, United States1995 to 2026Convicted
David Richard BerkowitzNew York State courts (Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx), United States1977 to 2026Pleaded guilty
Dennis Lynn RaderSedgwick County District Court, Kansas, United States2005 to 2026Pleaded guilty
Edward Theodore GeinWaushara County Circuit Court, Wisconsin, United States1957 to 1984Acquitted
Elizabeth Anne HolmesU.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (San Jose), United States2018 to 2026Convicted
Harold Frederick ShipmanCrown Court of England and Wales, United Kingdom2000 to 2004Convicted
Ivan Robert Marko MilatSupreme Court of New South Wales, Australia1994 to 2019Convicted
Jeffrey Lionel DahmerMilwaukee County Circuit Court, Wisconsin, United States1991 to 1994Convicted
John Wayne GacyCircuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, United States1980 to 1994Convicted
Joseph Lyle Menendez and Erik Galen MenendezLos Angeles County Superior Court, California, United States1990 to 2026Convicted
Lizzie Andrew BordenSuperior Court, Bristol County (sitting at New Bedford), Massachusetts, United States1892 to 1893Acquitted
Orenthal James SimpsonLos Angeles County Superior Court, California, and Clark County District Court, Nevada, United States1994 to 2024Convicted
Oscar Leonard Carl PistoriusHigh Court, Gauteng Division, Pretoria, and Supreme Court of Appeal, South Africa2014 to 2029Conviction overturned
Peter William Sutcliffe (later Peter Coonan)Central Criminal Court (Old Bailey), England and Wales, United Kingdom1981 to 2020Convicted
Richard RamirezLos Angeles County Superior Court, California, United States1989 to 2013Convicted
Scott Lee PetersonSan Mateo County Superior Court (case moved from Stanislaus County), California, United States2004 to 2026Convicted
Theodore John KaczynskiU.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California (with a case transferred from the District of New Jersey), United States1996 to 2023Pleaded guilty
Theodore Robert BundyFlorida and Utah state courts, United States1975 to 1989Convicted
Timothy James McVeighU.S. District Court for the District of Colorado (venue moved from Oklahoma City), United States1997 to 2001Convicted